Hey guys,
It has been pointed out that our League Guide was a little fuzzy on the way we score matches with an absent team member – because of that along with my own confusion, I have scored these matches incorrectly. Basically, I was giving away too many points to the team with a no-show. If Player A and B are playing together, and Player A no-shows, I had Player B playing both opponents for points (theoretically they could gain more than 10 points). This is wrong – Player B plays against one opponent for the match (the 10 points), and plays the other opponent as a “spoiler” – Player B cannot score points against the second opponent but only tries to minimize points against him in that match. So if your partner no-shows, it’s important to determine who you are playing against for the actual match and who you are playing against as the “spoiler” (only way I can think of it, sorry). This ensures there is still a penalty for having a no-show (you are not able to gain points for that match).
That’s my explanation of things, rest assured the League Guide will be updated and I can post that when complete – I just wanted to let you all know prior to this week’s matches that points have been updated. Thanks and sorry for any confusion – I’ll be around the keg tomorrow if you want to discuss further.
2017 WNL Standings-Week 5 UPDATED
Team #1 CTB goes from 128.5 to 122.5
Team #13 Putt 4 Dough goes from 117.5 to 111.5
Team #6 Six Pack goes from 115 to 109.5
Team #5 Last Call goes from 116 to 117
Team #8 Zed Heads goes from 104.5 to 105.5
From Roger Hamm:
The current language in the league guide is misleading/confusing as it states in one area:
“If a Player is deemed Absent, and no Substitute was assigned, then the Absent Player’s teammate plays both opponents based on his own handicap for the purpose of awarding the 9 points for Match Play.”
— which is technically true, but the solo player only can win one set of points, not two.
and it states in another area:
“In case of an Absent player, the team with one player will play both matches/competitors for the 10 Match Points. The lone player is playing two matches at the same time on each hole.”
— which is very misleading. It is possible for all 10 points to be awarded in the absent player vs player 2 match, but the solo player would have to lose every hole, so 10 Match Play points is unlikely to happen in this case.
As Brad wrote the description above is the most accurate description we have of the intent of the rule. The rule for absent and late players is unchanged from 2016. However, the league guide poorly describes it and there was a scoring error in the database. The database is fixed. The newly revised league guide is here: http://bmga.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/2017_League_Guide-revised.pdf
Sorry for the confusion – RH